Tillys Return Policy: 30 Days With a Receipt, a $6.95 Mail Fee and Free Returns in Store

Tillys’ return policy gives you 30 days from the package order date or the store purchase date to return an item, with your receipt and everything still attached — tags on, original packaging intact, and no tape or shipping labels on the shoebox. Mailed returns cost a $6.95 return fee when you create the label, but taking the same return to a Tillys store is free, and the store can process your refund on the spot. The rule with no exceptions is the receipt: Tillys states plainly that it does not accept returns without a receipt. This guide covers the window, the final-sale list, the holiday extension and how each return route works.

Return Period

30 days from package order date or store purchase date

Mail Return Fee

$6.95 when you create a return label

In-Store Returns

Free, with items and shipping confirmation email

No Receipt

No returns without a receipt — Tillys.com does not accept them

Return Windows at a Glance

CategoryReturn windowGood to know
Most merchandise30 days from package order date or store purchase dateReceipt required; original condition and packaging, tickets and garment labels attached
Holiday purchases (October–December)30 days or through 15 January of the following year, whichever is laterThe published holiday extension
Online purchases returned in store30 days from package order dateFree; bring the original shipping receipt and the card used for the order
Online purchases returned by mail30 days from package order date$6.95 fee when you create the return label
Bikes, surfboards, paddleboards, snowboards, snowboard boots and bindings30 daysMail return only — cannot be returned in store
APO/FPO orders30 daysContact customer service to coordinate the return
Jewelry, undies, cosmetics, candy, clearance promotions (red tag/price), donationsFinal saleCannot be returned
TikTok and Amazon purchases30 daysRefund to original payment only if returned through TikTok or Amazon; in-store returns get an exchange or Store Credit, no refunds

How to Return an Item to Tillys

  1. Check your window and your receipt. You have 30 days from the package order date for an online order, or from the store purchase date for a store purchase. Find your receipt — Tillys does not accept returns without one — and check the item is in its original condition with tickets and garment labels attached and the original packaging intact.
  2. For a free return, take it to a store. Bring the items and your shipping confirmation email to your nearest Tillys store. The store can process your refund with no additional fees. Bring the credit or debit card you used for the order as well as the original shipping receipt.
  3. For a mail return, create a return label online. Use the online returns portal linked from the Returns & Exchanges page to create your label. A $6.95 return fee is charged when you create the label, and return shipping fees are collected at the time of label creation — the cost is calculated once you have selected your eligible items.
  4. Ship it back through USPS. Place your return package in your mailbox, a USPS blue collection box, hand it to your postal carrier, drop it at any post office, or request a free carrier pickup at usps.com/pickup. Track it at usps.com with your tracking number.
  5. Or send it yourself, pre-paid and insured. If you do not want a Tillys return label, send your pre-paid, insured package to Tillys.com E-Commerce Returns, 17 Pasteur, Irvine, CA 92618. Tillys cannot accept C.O.D. deliveries.

How Long Do You Have to Return Items to Tillys

The standard window is 30 days from the package order date for online orders and 30 days from the store purchase date for store purchases. The one stated exception is orders shipped to APO/FPO addresses, which fall outside the standard route — contact customer service to coordinate those returns rather than using the portal.

Condition matters as much as timing. Items need to be in their original condition and original packaging, with tickets and garment labels attached. Shoeboxes have their own rule: they must not have tape or shipping labels on them — so do not stick the return label on the shoebox itself. Shipping fees are nonrefundable, and Tillys states it will not provide a refund for any item it does not receive or that does not otherwise comply with the Return Policy.

What Can’t Be Returned to Tillys?

Tillys publishes a final-sale list, and anything on it cannot be returned:

  • Jewelry
  • Undies
  • Cosmetics
  • Candy
  • Clearance promotions — items with a red tag or red price
  • Donations

Two more categories are not returnable to Tillys in the usual sense: for sunglasses and watches, Tillys directs you to contact the manufacturer for warranty coverage rather than returning them to the store. And the bulky hardgoods — bikes, surfboards, paddleboards, snowboards, snowboard boots and bindings — cannot be returned in store at all; they must be returned by mail.

Items bought through TikTok or Amazon have their own split. They may be refunded to the original payment if returned through TikTok or Amazon, but if you bring them to a Tillys store they can only be exchanged or refunded as a Store Credit — no refunds. So for a TikTok or Amazon purchase, the platform’s own return route is the only way to get your money back.

Can You Exchange an Online Order at Tillys?

Not directly. Tillys states that it does not offer exchanges for online purchases: to change a size or colour on an online order, you return the item and place a new order. The one alternative is to visit a local Tillys store, where an exchange is possible. That makes the in-store route the better choice when you know you want a different size rather than your money back — you can swap on the spot instead of waiting for a refund and reordering.

For Afterpay orders, the same shape applies with a payment twist: they can be returned online back to your Afterpay account, or returned to a store for an even exchange. Refunds go from Tillys to Afterpay, and Tillys cannot provide cash refunds on Afterpay orders.

How Do Gift Card Returns Work at Tillys?

Items paid for with a Tillys Gift Card can be returned under the regular Return Policy, but the refund does not go back to your bank: it is issued as a Store Credit in the form of a Tillys Gift Card, valid for merchandise online or at any Tillys retail store. Tillys advises keeping your Gift Card until you have received the item when making an online purchase, since the card is part of the return record. If a Gift Card is lost or stolen, it cannot be replaced without the original sales receipt, and the replacement value is the remaining value on the card at the time you report the loss — report it to customer service at customerservice@tillys.com or on 866-4TILLYS (866-484-5597). A Gift Card cannot be redeemed for cash unless the law where you live requires it, so treat the card like cash and keep it somewhere safe.

Can You Return to Tillys Without a Receipt?

No. This is the firmest rule in Tillys’ policy: Tillys.com does not accept returns without a receipt, and the Returns & Exchanges page repeats that a receipt is required for all returns. If you bought online and no longer have the receipt, Tillys can send you a new receipt for your online purchase if you request one — so ask for that before you start the return. For anything else, visit the contact us page for methods of contact and hours of operation. Keep the shipping confirmation email for online orders: it is the receipt the store will ask for, and it is also what makes the in-store return free.

How Are Refunds Issued and How Long Do They Take?

Returns are processed when the item is received by Tillys’ returns department — not when you drop the parcel off. Refunds for eligible returned merchandise are issued back to the original method of payment, and Tillys asks you to allow 1 to 2 billing cycles for the credit to appear on your statement. That is a longer wait than most retailers quote, so a mail return can take several weeks from drop-off to the credit showing up.

Return routeHow the refund works
In storeProcessed by the store with no additional fees; refund to the original method of payment
By mail, with a return label$6.95 fee deducted; refund to the original method of payment once the returns department receives the item; allow 1 to 2 billing cycles
By mail, own pre-paid insured parcelSame refund terms; sent to Tillys.com E-Commerce Returns, 17 Pasteur, Irvine, CA 92618
Paid with a Tillys Gift CardRefund issued as a Store Credit (a Tillys Gift Card), valid online or at any Tillys retail store
Paid with AfterpayRefunded from Tillys to Afterpay; no cash refunds
TikTok or Amazon purchase, returned in storeExchange or Store Credit only — no refunds

Does Tillys Extend Returns for the Holidays?

Yes. Tillys publishes a holiday rule on its Returns & Exchanges page: holiday purchases made October through December are accepted for 30 days or through January 15 of the following year, whichever is later. A purchase made in early October therefore gets until 15 January, not just 30 days, and a purchase made in late December gets 30 days from the purchase date if that runs past 15 January. If you are Christmas shopping at Tillys, the January date is the one to remember — but keep the receipt, because the holiday extension does not waive the receipt requirement.

Tillys Contact Options

OptionDetails
Online Customer Service866-4TILLYS (866-484-5597)
Emailcustomerservice@tillys.com
Return label / online returns portalLinked from the Returns & Exchanges page on tillys.com
Mail returns addressTillys.com E-Commerce Returns, 17 Pasteur, Irvine, CA 92618 (pre-paid, insured; no C.O.D.)
In storeAny Tillys store — bring items, shipping confirmation email, original receipt and the card used
APO/FPO returnsContact customer service to coordinate
Contact pagetillys.com contact us page for methods of contact and hours of operation

Tillys on Social Media

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Tillys · Instagram: https://instagram.com/tillys/ · Pinterest: https://pinterest.com/tillys/ · TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tillys · YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/tillys

These are Tillys’ official brand profiles. Tillys does not handle returns through social media — for anything about an order, the phone number and email address in the contact table above are the routes that will actually resolve it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Returns are accepted within 30 days of the package order date or store purchase date, with a receipt, in original condition and packaging with tags attached. Mailed returns cost a $6.95 fee when you create the label; in-store returns are free. Tillys does not accept returns without a receipt.

A $6.95 return fee is charged when you create a return label, and return shipping fees are collected at label creation. To avoid the fee entirely, take the items and your shipping confirmation email to your nearest Tillys store — in-store returns are free.

No. Tillys states that it does not accept returns without a receipt, and a receipt is required for all returns. If you bought online, Tillys can send you a new receipt for your online purchase if you request one.

Jewelry, undies, cosmetics, candy, clearance promotions (red tag or red price) and donations are final sale. Sunglasses and watches go through the manufacturer’s warranty instead of a Tillys return.

Not by mail. Tillys does not offer exchanges for online purchases — you return the item and place a new order. You can exchange in a Tillys store instead, which is the faster route if you want a different size or colour.

Returns are processed when the item reaches Tillys’ returns department, and refunds go back to the original method of payment. Allow 1 to 2 billing cycles for the credit to appear on your statement. In-store returns are processed by the store on the spot.

Yes. Holiday purchases made October through December are accepted for 30 days or through 15 January of the following year, whichever is later. The receipt requirement still applies.

Yes, but the route matters. Returns made through TikTok or Amazon can be refunded to the original payment method. If you bring the item to a Tillys store instead, you can only get an exchange or a Store Credit — no refunds.

Related Guides

Conclusion

Tillys’ return policy is straightforward but unforgiving on paperwork: 30 days, original condition with tags attached, a $6.95 fee on mailed returns, free returns in store — and no return at all without a receipt. The holiday extension to 15 January softens the Christmas rush, and the in-store route is the best move in almost every case: no fee, an exchange on the spot, and a refund processed while you wait. Keep the shipping confirmation email, keep the tags on, and do not tape anything to the shoebox — those three habits cover almost every Tillys return problem before it starts. If you paid with Afterpay or a gift card, expect the refund to follow the payment method — back to Afterpay, or back onto a Tillys Gift Card — rather than arriving as cash.

Disclaimer: Policy Return is an independent guide and is not affiliated with Tillys. Return policies can change at any time; always confirm the current policy on Tillys’ official website before making a return.

Checked against Tillys’ published policy on 15 November 2026. Policies change; the retailer’s official page is the final word.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *